SWINDLE COLUMN: The other man’s shoes

Published 8:30 am Tuesday, July 20, 2021

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

There is no client as scary as an innocent man.” Michael Connelly – The Lincoln Lawyer

Protecting people who have been accused of a crime has an honorable history. 

In 1770, before our country was founded, British soldiers were charged with murdering five Boston residents in what became known as the Boston Massacre. Passions ran high against the British soldiers and few were willing to step to their defense. One who did was a prominent lawyer who skillfully and successfully defended the soldiers in the face of cries for mob justice.  He did not defend the British soldiers out of love for their cause. Rather, he defended them out of his love for the cause of justice and his fervent belief that anyone accused of a crime has a right to counsel.

Fortunately, the citizenry did not view his role as a defense lawyer in the Boston Massacre trials as being anything but an act of integrity. Just three months after he agreed to represent the British soldiers, John Adams was elected to the Massachusetts legislature. As a delegate from Massachusetts, he was a leading advocate for independence from Britain and assisted Thomas Jefferson in writing the Declaration of Independence. When the newly formed United States held its first election for president, George Washington was unanimously elected. Under the rules then in place, the recipient of second highest vote, John Adams, became Vice President. He went on to succeed Washington to become the second President of the United States.

Today, criminal defense attorneys are acting in the best traditions of our Founding Fathers; like John Adams.

Unfortunately, some well-known former criminal defense attorneys are not so proud of their former work and even perpetuate the myth that someone accused of a crime must be guilty. 

Some of our public servants provide the worst and most inaccurate message to the public as well.  When Tim Kaine ran for office in 2016, he was blasted because he “has a passion for defending the wrong people” and that “long before Kaine was in office, he consistently protected the worst kinds of people.”

I wonder how many of these folks would have the courage to look John Adams in the eye and make such statements. Probably zero. 

When it becomes acceptable to assume that everyone who happens to get arrested is presumed guilty and those who defend them are subject to verbal attacks fail to forcefully respond, our Constitutional Republic has truly lost its way. This can be averted by thinking about what it is like to walk in the other man’s shoes.